Ranking retailers on toxic chemicals

Ranking retailers on toxic chemicals

  • Act Now
  • Retailers
  • Report Card
    • Executive Summary
    • Introduction
    • Retailer Rankings
    • Key Findings
    • Conclusion & Recommendations
    • Resources
    • Methodology
  • About
  • News

Panera Bread

D+


  • Panera Bread

Panera Bread is making progress in addressing key toxic indirect food additives that may be in food contact materials. Panera Bread earned a letter grade of D+, a significant improvement over its score of F in 2018. The company scored 34.25 out of 146.5 points, ranking 25th out of 43 retailers.

Panera Bread has established a safer chemicals policy that restricts substances in food packaging (and serves to prevent the introduction of these substances from the packaging into the food), that goes beyond regulatory compliance and includes PFAS, bisphenols, and phthalates. However, the company has not publicly disclosed its beyond restricted substance list (BRSL). The company has also moved from PVC gloves (which may contain phthalates) to polyethylene gloves (that are free of phthalates) for food handling, restricts chemicals of concern in cleaning products, and has started the process for switching one type of to-go packaging (baguette bags) to PFAS-free materials.

Opportunities for improvement: Panera Bread can make progress by fully disclosing its packaging BRSL and developing a comprehensive public written safer chemicals policy that ensures supplier compliance with the policy, sets quantifiable goals with clear timelines (beyond moving away from PFAS in baguette bags), and completely eliminates and safely replaces any toxic indirect food additives that may be in food contact materials. The company should disclose its efforts and progress in eliminating chemicals of high concern from food packaging, including any PFAS that may be in food packaging besides baguette bags. Panera should also become a signatory to the Chemical Footprint Project and pilot it with suppliers.

Share2
Tweet
Email

Summary of Panera Bread’s Grade

11.25 out of 17.5 points

Policy: Adopted a retailer safer chemicals policy

Explanation of Points

Panera Bread has a written safer chemicals policy that includes a restricted substances list (RSL) for to-go food packaging that goes beyond regulatory compliance and serves to prevent the introduction of chemicals into the food. Panera Bread’s policy also applies to its operations: it restricts chemicals used in cleaning products and replaced PVC disposable gloves for food handling with gloves made from polyethylene that are free of phthalates.

This policy applies only to US locations, which are 88% of all Panera cafes.

Panera Bread’s 2015-2016 Responsibility Report, the most recent report available online, describes the company’s Restricted Substance List (RSL) for packaging but does not provide details about the chemicals on it. While this RSL is not public at this time, a Panera employee verified that it includes flourinated chemicals, phthalates, and bisphenols. The RSL serves as a BRSL for certain chemicals. Staff noted in September 2019 that “All new packages are assessed against our RSL. In addition, we are reviewing our legacy portfolio against the RSL. We aim to have this review completed by mid-2020.”

In October 2019, staff stated: “This Fall, we are switching over our first package, our baguette bag, over to PFC-free paper. Cafes will be fully transitioned by June 2020.” Partial credit is awarded for Panera Bread setting limited public quantifiable goals. Staff later clarified that PFC, in this context, means per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS).

Panera Bread has also established a “Food Policy” and a “No No List” for chemicals that it does not allow in its food.

The company has not established public quantifiable goals for reducing other chemicals of concern and does not have a publicly available manufacturing restricted substance list (MRSL).

2.5 out of 5 points

Oversight: Established management responsibilities and incentives

Explanation of Points

Panera Bread has assigned a member of senior management, the senior manager of corporate social responsibility, with responsibility for chemicals and packaging. Panera’s 2015-2016 Responsibility Report states: “We have a dedicated corporate responsibility team that is charged with managing our overall responsibility strategy, responsibility reporting and stakeholder engagement. This same team drives cross-functional initiatives on key environmental, animal welfare and philanthropy programs. In addition, subject matter experts across the company share accountability for driving other responsibility initiatives, such as our focus on health and wellness, clean ingredients and sustainable packaging, among others.”

Panera notes that “senior leaders are held accountable for responsibility metrics in the same way they are for general business performance.” However, it is not clear if these metrics are tied to financial incentives.

Panera notes: “There is no specific Board committee to oversee corporate responsibility and sustainability, but the Board is regularly briefed on relevant social and environmental issues as well as any stockholder resolutions that may arise.”

2.5 out of 12.5 points

Accountability: Ensures supply chain accountability

Explanation of Points

Panera Bread noted that “Suppliers must sign that they are in compliance with our [B]RSL,” so credit is awarded for the contract component.

Although the company stated that it assesses packaging materials for compliance with its BRSL, Panera Bread has not specifically disclosed that it trains suppliers on the company’s safer chemicals policy or reporting requirements, that it requires suppliers to conduct testing in third-party laboratories and provide results to the retailer, or that it conducts its own testing to ensure suppliers comply with its safer chemicals policy

2.5 out of 13 points

Disclosure: Requires suppliers to report use of chemicals in products to retailer

Explanation of Points

In October 2019, Panera Bread staff noted to us: “For to-go packaging, we review all intentionally added substances including generic ingredients. Suppliers must sign that they are in compliance with our RSL and submit a list of all ingredients.” The company also works with an external consultant whose staff “review all intentionally added ingredients as well as evaluate reactions between chemicals in their review for packaging safety.”

The company does not require known impurities in packaging to be reported, and it does not seem as though they review the specific components of generic ingredients. Panera Bread’s disclosure requirements only apply to “all of our to-go packaging” (e.g., own-brand) and not “packaged foods from other vendors.”

6 out of 16 points

Action: Reduced or eliminated chemicals of high concern (CHCs) within the last three years

Explanation of Points

Panera Bread has documented that it has completely eliminated PVC gloves and moved to polyethylene gloves (that are free of phthalates) within the last year.

The company also disclosed upcoming progress on PFAS in noting that it is starting to switch over its baguette bag to PFC-free paper this Fall and cafes will be fully transitioned to this paper by June 2020.

2 out of 13.5 points

Safer Alternatives: Evaluates safer alternatives, avoids regrettable substitutes

Explanation of Points

Panera Bread is aware of the emerging issue of short-chain perfluorinated chemicals in packaging and expresses a clear preference for safer alternatives to PFAS chemicals in food packaging through its work with external stakeholders. Staff noted in September 2019: “All new packages entering the system must meet the requirements outlined in our RSL” and “We also continue to find alternatives for existing packages that contain PFCs.”

0 out of 18 points

Transparency: Demonstrates a commitment to transparency and public disclosure

Explanation of Points

Panera Bread indicates that it has a BRSL related to food packaging, but has not publicly disclosed the contents of the BRSL itself. Panera Bread has disclosed its “No No List” of prohibited direct food additives, but that is not relevant for the purposes of this report card.

Panera Bread does not appear to encourage or require suppliers to publicly disclose all indirect food additives in food contact materials and does not publicly disclose the identity of food contact materials that are currently free of CHCs that are indirect food additives going beyond regulatory compliance.

0 out of 7.5 points

Chemical Footprint: Evaluates its chemical footprint

Explanation of Points

Panera Bread has not made any discernible progress on measuring its chemical footprint via the Chemical Footprint Project.

0 out of 8.5 points

Third-party Standards: Promotes credible third party standards for safer products

Explanation of Points

Panera Bread has not shown discernible progress on credible third-party safer chemicals standards going beyond regulatory compliance.

Extra Credit:

0 out of 5 points

Joint Announcement: Public commitment demonstrated through joint announcement

Explanation of Points

Panera Bread has not made a discernible public commitment through a joint announcement or other coordination effort in advance of a major announcement within the time periods specified in the scoring rubric.

7.5 out of 15 points

Continuous Improvement: Shows continuous improvement by steadily expanding safer chemicals policy

Explanation of Points

Panera Bread significantly improved its management of chemicals by fully replacing PVC gloves for food handling with polyethylene gloves that are free of phthalates. The company has also set a timeline for moving to PFC-free baguette bags, and partial credit above 5 points is awarded for this small but important additional improvement in Panera’s chemical management.

0 out of 5 points

Safer Products: Program to promote safer products in stores and/or on website

Explanation of Points

Panera Bread has no discernible program to feature and market safer food contact materials used at its restaurants.

0 out of 5 points

Collaboration: Actively participates in collaborative process to promote safer chemicals

Explanation of Points

There is no indication that the retailer actively participates in a collaborative process or retains an independent expert body to promote safer chemicals or that it has created an external advisory board to provide input on implementation of the policy.

0 out of 5 points

Impact Investment: Investing financial resources into independent research into safer alternatives and/or green chemistry solutions

Explanation of Points

There is no indication that the retailer invests significant financial resources into independent research into safer alternatives to CHCs and/or green chemistry solutions.

Grade
D+
Points
34.25
Take Action
D+

Tweet to @panerabread

@PaneraBread earned only a D+ for actions on toxic chemicals from RetailerReportCard.com?! More progress please! #MindTheStore #Panera https://retailerreportcard.com/retailer/panera-bread/Click To Tweet
Summary of Panera Bread’s Grade
2018 2019
F D+

Select retailer

Read the Report

Who's Minding the Store?

© 2019 Safer Chemicals, Healthy Families.
All rights reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer